The Pantry

Pantry Staples

The flavor builders. The things that make everything else taste better — sourced with the same care as everything else we carry.

Known Producers No Fillers or Additives Small-Batch Made
Filter by use:
30 products
The One We Never Run Out Of Tortello Pomodoro Sauce (12 oz)

Tortello

Tortello Pomodoro Sauce (12 oz)

Tortello Pomodoro Sauce — 12 ozA bright, simple tomato sauce from Tortello, Chicago’s handmade pa...

$15.00

View Details →

Tortello

4.8
Hand Made Italian Pasta - Tortello - 12oz - 16oz

When making something with only two ingredients, everything needs to be perfe...

$15.00

Iron & Acre

4.8
Daily Protein Powder

One ingredient. No aftertaste. No junk. Cold-filtered whey protein isolate so...

“So fresh. So easy. Already looking at upgrading.” — Conrad S.

$58.00

Iron & Acre

4.8
Rendered Beef Tallow (1 Pint)

The original cooking fat, back where it belongs. One pint of rendered beef tall...

“No crap, no shortcuts. You can taste the difference.” — M.E.

From $15.00

Iron & Acre

4.8
Naturally Fermented Sauerkraut - 24oz

Cabbage, salt, and time. That's it. Twenty-four ounces of naturally fermented ...

“Excellent quality — the real thing.” — Jordaan

$17.00

Iron & Acre

4.8
Local Raw Honey

Light, delicate, and uniquely local. This raw honey is harvested from bees for...

“Sweet fragrant flavor — we made a honey marinade for chicken and it was incredible.” — M.E.

From $16.00

Iron & Acre

4.8
Pure Wisconsin Maple Syrup (Pint)

Real maple syrup from a farm that taps trees. A pint of pure maple syrup from a...

“It made dinner planning actually fun.” — Amanda K.

$18.00

Alden Hills

4.8
Pasture Raised Chicken Broth (24oz)

The broth that makes everything else taste better. Twenty-four ounces of slow-s...

“The best quality in the area — every single time.” — Melissa E.

$18.00

The Wild Roaster

4.8
The Wild Roaster Coffee

After all, great food requires great coffee. The Wild Roaster is a small-batch...

“We’ve tried several boxes, and this one wins by a mile.” — Johnny S.

From $21.95

Cahokia Rice

4.8
Cahokia Rice - High Protein Wild Rice (2lb Bag)

The rice your pantry has been missing. Cahokia Rice is a high-protein wild rice...

“Everything was fresh, easy to cook, and local.” — Jason P.

$12.00

Iron & Acre

4.8
Organic Rolled Oats (32oz)

The oat that actually tastes like oats. Thirty-two ounces of certified organic ...

“Helps mix things up in a good way with our meal planning.” — Dan

$10.00

Janie's Mill

4.8
Janie's Mill - Organic All-Purpose Flour (3lb)

The flour that makes everything you bake taste more like itself. Three pounds o...

“No waste, always fresh, and the quality is top-notch.” — Sean S.

$13.00

Janie's Mill

4.8
Janie's Mill - Organic High-Protein Bread Flour (3lb)

The flour serious bread bakers reach for. Three pounds of stone-milled organic ...

“We love knowing where our food comes from.” — Sean S.

$14.00

Iron & Acre

4.8
Doudlah Farms Organic Popcorn Kernels (3lb)

Popcorn grown in real soil, not a commodity system. Three pounds of organic pop...

“No crap in the corn, no GMO. You can taste the difference.” — M.E.

From $15.00

Iron & Acre

4.8
Doudlah Farms Organic Dry Beans

The pantry staple that actually has a farm behind it. Organic dry beans from Do...

“No GMO, no shortcuts. You can taste the difference.” — M.E.

$8.00

Iron & Acre

4.8
Cashew Butter infused with Lions Mane

Now in a larger 10oz jar. Creamy cashew butter with Lion’s Mane extract, cinn...

“The quality and care is next level.” — Ryan

$18.00

Bushel & Peck's

4.8
Bushel & Peck's Apple Butter (8 oz)

Apples and cinnamon cooked into a smooth, deeply comforting spread from Bushel ...

$10.00

Bushel & Peck's

4.8
Bushel & Peck's Raspberry Jam (8 oz)

Tart, sweet and fruit-forward raspberry jam from Bushel & Peck's in Beloit,...

$10.00

Bushel & Peck's

4.8
Bushel & Peck's Peach Jalapeño Jam (8 oz)

Ripe peach sweetness followed by a gentle jalapeño finish, made by Bushel &...

$10.00

Bushel & Peck's

4.8
Bushel & Peck's Cherry Bomb Hot Sauce (5 oz)

A smoky hot sauce with curry and garlic from Bushel & Peck's in Beloit, Wis...

$8.00

Bushel & Peck's

4.8
Bushel & Peck's Jalapeño Lime Hot Sauce (5 oz)

A bright, verde-style hot sauce built around jalapeño and lime, made by Bushel ...

$8.00

Bushel & Peck's

4.8
Bushel & Peck's Belizean Habanero Hot Sauce (5 oz)

Habanero and carrot come together in a hot sauce designed for balanced heat and...

$8.00

Bushel & Peck's

4.8
Bushel & Peck's Garden Salsa (11.5 oz)

A mild, tomato-forward garden salsa from Bushel & Peck's in Beloit, Wiscons...

$10.00

Bushel & Peck's

4.8
Bushel & Peck's Puttanesca Sauce (24 oz)

A savory Italian tomato sauce with olives, capers and anchovies from Bushel &am...

$15.00

Bushel & Peck's

4.8
Bushel & Peck's Squash Bisque (32 oz)

A smooth, warming bisque made with squash, carrots, garlic and spices by Bushel...

$14.00

Bushel & Peck's

4.8
Bushel & Peck's Beet Ketchup (10 oz)

A bright, earthy ketchup made with beets by Bushel & Peck's in Beloit, Wisc...

$11.00

Wisco Kitchen

4.8
Wisco Kitchen Giardiniera (16 oz)

Chicago-style giardiniera with peppers, carrots and cauliflower from Wisco Kitc...

$12.00

Bushel & Peck's

4.8
Iron & Acre Hot Sauce Flight (3 × 5 oz)

Three small-batch Bushel & Peck's hot sauces, selected as a progression fro...

$24.00

Bushel & Peck's

4.8
Bushel & Peck's Pizza Sauce (12 oz)

Weeknight pizza made easy with a tomato-rich sauce from Bushel & Peck's in ...

$8.00

Iron & Acre

4.8
Local Raw Linden Honey

Bright, floral and unlike the honey most of us grew up with. Linden honey is m...

From $16.00
Brenneman Country Store
Meet a Producer

Brenneman Country Store

An Amish-run country store in Grabill, Indiana. The Brenneman family grows, mills, and packs many of the pantry staples we carry — from heritage grains to raw honey. Everything is made in small batches with ingredients you can actually name.

Meet All Our Producers →
Pantry Cooking

Low and Slow, Done Right

Brats with Warm Sauerkraut, Muenster and Toasted Ciabatta
Brats with Warm Sauerkraut, Muenster and Toasted Ciabatta
From the Kitchen
Bacon-Cheddar English Muffin Burgers with Roasted Seasonal Vegetables
Bacon-Cheddar English Muffin Burgers with Roasted Seasonal Vegetables
From the Kitchen
Pan-Seared Wild Salmon with Cahokia Rice and Weekly Greens
Pan-Seared Wild Salmon with Cahokia Rice and Weekly Greens
From the Kitchen
Browse All Recipes →

Our Pantry Essentials

Beef tallow for cooking, raw honey for everything, and chicken broth for soups. Those three cover 80% of what we reach for every week.

Use It With

Pantry staples are better when the protein is too.
Pasture-Raised Chicken Breasts (2 lbs)
Pasture-Raised Chicken Breasts (2 lbs) $32.00
Pasture Raised Whole Chicken (4-6 lbs)
Pasture Raised Whole Chicken (4-6 lbs) $32.00
Pasture-Raised Chicken Thighs (2 lbs)
Pasture-Raised Chicken Thighs (2 lbs) $26.00
Pasture Raised Ground Chicken (2 lbs)
Pasture Raised Ground Chicken (2 lbs) $31.00
Pasture-Raised Chicken Wings (10)
Pasture-Raised Chicken Wings (10) $26.00
100% Grass-Fed Burger Patties (Pack of 6)
100% Grass-Fed Burger Patties (Pack o... $32.00
Grass Fed Ground Beef Bundle (2 lbs)
Grass Fed Ground Beef Bundle (2 lbs) $29.00
Beef Broth Bones (2-4lbs)
Beef Broth Bones (2-4lbs) $15.00

We think about the pantry the same way we think about produce — it should come from somewhere specific, made by someone you could actually call. Beef tallow rendered from our own grass-fed beef. Raw honey from a beekeeper we know. Real maple syrup from Wisconsin.

Known Producers No Fillers or Additives Small-Batch Made Make-It-Right Guarantee

Meals Made Easy

Start with a meal, not a longer list

Salmon, rice and greens are visible Dinner for Two Wild Salmon Dinner Choose Coho or Keta salmon, then pair it with Cahokia rice and this week’s greens. Add garlic-basil butter or lemons when they are available and useful to you. $64.00Serves 2 See the meal